AI Refuses to Draw Flat Earth
So I did an experiment with an AI art generator (craiyon).
Here is the image I was trying to get it to draw (or at least something similar)
using text prompts.
This was just an experiment to see what AI would draw. The
results were not what I expected (although I should have). Here are the text
prompts and the results. I even included negative words, which are things that
the AI is supposed to avoid. Instead, I think it just reinforced the idea. See
for yourself.
I thought this prompt was pretty straight forward. It's a fairly
accurate description of the image above. Here's what I got.
OK. I'll give it the benefit of the doubt. Maybe the AI didn't
understand what "Flat Earth" or "AE Map" means. I added the negative word
"globe" to see if that helped. I used the same prompt for this one.
I thought that would help. I was mistaken. Here is the result.
As you can see, I'm still getting globes. I did, however, get
one Mercator projection with the moon over it. One image seemed to be a flat
plane earth with the sun and moon over it but it appearsed to be the roof of a
house and there was no dome. One of the images was square, which I thought was
interesting.
At least we're on the right path,
right? I thought so, but no. OK. Let's try that again, but we'll add a few more
negative words. Let's just be clear what we're NOT looking for.
OK. We're NOT looking for a globe, planet, sphere, or ball ...
of any kind. The AI had other plans.
The AI (ChatGPT) gave me a suggestion for the prompt. OK. I'll
give that a try.
Still using the same negative words, I gave the new suggested
prompt a try.
Surely that would give me the desired result, right? I mean,
it should work, right? It was the AI's suggestion.
Only one of the images even comes close to trying to be a flat
earth. I'm still getting globes and planets "in space". The AI gave me a new
suggestion. OK. Let's try that one.
That sounded reasonable. That was close to what I started with
though. Still using the same negative words, I gave the new suggested
prompt a try. Well, here's the result of that.
A couple of the images appear to be flat but the globe images
are still dominating the results. I'm about at my wit's end. What do I have to
do to get a flat earth picture?
I really can't be any more specific than that. There doesn't
seem to be a need for negative words with this prompt. Let's see what happens.
Yeah. I'm done. This AI just refuses to draw a picture of Flat
Earth. You're welcome to try other AI web sites if you like. This one is free
and has no limit on the number of images you can make. Others are pay sites and
others require an account you need to sign up for. Some have free credits but
they are very few and your options are limited unless you pay up.
Take it for what it's worth. I'm convinced that (at least this)
AI is programmed by glerbers (globe heads).
___________________________________________________________________________________
Well, it's been a couple months now since this experiment. I
decided to give it another go. This time I found a few other AI art generators
online. This time I tried img2go. Remember these are simply text prompts so it's
limited to the description of the one typing and also by its programming of
course.
This was my first attempt with this AI.
Again, I started with a simple description of what I was
after. Here is the result. I have to admit, it really tried. It really did.
AS you can see, the AI started with the globe and took it from
there. What I wound up getting was a snow globe with the earth globe inside but
flattened on top. I have to give it credit for trying. OK. Let's try again. This
time being a bit more specific.
I added the A.E. Map and told it I didn't want a globe. Fair
enough? I thought so. AI had other ideas.
It still gave me a globe even though I specifically told it
not to. What do you think? Should I give it another chance? Sure. Why not.
Let's try switching things around a bit. This time I gave it 2 chances with the
same prompt just to see what would happen.
I thought I'd try to see if it would add stars to the dome. I
wasn't expecting much at this point.
I really like the second picture but it still isn't what I'm
trying to achieve. I don't know why this is so hard for AI to do. It's obviously
programmed to avoid the end result I'm trying to get it to draw. I can't think
of any other reason it would absolutely refuse to do so.
It seems like just about any other image I ask it to draw, it
does a much better job. Just to prove the point, here is another image I asked
for.
The Steampunk Robot Bar.
(I edited the FLERF sign. I'm sure that's not what it said but it sure looked
like it.
)
|